Minimum length sum path

Minimum length sum pathZahid Rahman

Given a binary tree, find out the minimum length sum path form root to leaf with sum S. What about finding minimum length sum path for BST? How does BST improve the search?

For example, the min length path for sum S=13 in T1 is 2 (6–>7 not, 6–>4–>3). For T2 min length path for sum S=3 is 3 (3–> -2 –>3).

    
                    T1                T2        
                    6                  3                   
                /      \             /
               4        7           -2
            /     \                    \
           3       5                     2               

For a binary tree, in order to find path re usually do a DFS search. So, we will do a modified DFS in this case to track min length path.

1. Compute difference between sum and current node value. Also keep tracking length of the current path.
2. If the difference is zero and the node is a leaf that means we got a path. Increase the path length by 1 and return it.
3. Otherwise, we keep searching for the path down to current nodes left and right child for the new sum = difference. Return the length of the minimum of the two paths.

private int minLenSumPathBT(final TreeNode root, final int sum, final int len) {
    if (root == null) {
        return Integer.MAX_VALUE;
    }

    final int diff = sum - root.key;
    if (diff == 0 && root.left == null && root.right == null) {
        return len + 1;
    } else {
        return Math.min(minLenSumPathBST(root.left, diff, len + 1), minLenSumPathBST(root.right, diff, len + 1));
    }
}

Min length sum-path for BST
With a BST we have an added advantage that we know all the nodes on the left is less than the current node and all the nodes on the right are greater than the current node.

For example with T1 and S=13, while we are at node 6 then we look for min path by traversing both left and right subtree for sum S=(13-6)=7. But if we knew that T1 is a BST while traversing node 6 then we could simply ignore the left subtree because the remaining sum 7 is greater than current node.

So, while doing a DFS to search for a minLen path in a BST we actually can take informed decision at each node to either go left or right based on the remaining sum to search and hence cutting down the search space in half in average case. This will guarantee finding the minimum length path because –

1. If current node value is equal to sum and it is a leaf node than we have a complete path. If it is not a leaf then we need to find a zero sum minLen path along one of its subtrees.
2. If current node value is greater than (or equal to) the remaining sum i.e. value>=(sum-value) then we should search for new sum=(sum-value) in the left sub tree because – if a path exists in the left subtree, it must be the shorter than any possible path in the right subtree, since all nodes at left is smaller than those at right. If such path doesn’t exists, only then we also search in the right subtree.
3. Similarly, If current node value is smaller than the remaining sum i.e. value<(sum-value) then we should search for new sum=(sum-value) in the right sub tree because – if a path exists in the right subtree, it must be the shorter than any possible path in the right subtree, since all nodes at right is greater than those at left. If such path doesn’t exists, only then we also search in the left subtree.

So, average case complexity will be improved to O(lgn) with a complete BST. However, the worst case complexity will be O(n) in case where we have to search both left and right subtree for the remaining sum.

private int minLenSumPathBST(final TreeNode root, final int sum, final int len) {
    if (root == null) {
        return Integer.MAX_VALUE;
    }

    // find the remaining sum as we are including current node in the current path
    final int remainingSum = sum - root.key;
    // If remaining sum is zero and it is a leaf node then we found a complete path from root to a leaf.
    if (remainingSum == 0 && root.left == null && root.right == null) {
        return len + 1;
    }
    // If remaining sum is less than current node value then we search remaining in the left subtree.
    else if (remainingSum <= root.key) {
      int l = minLenSumPathBST(root.left, remainingSum, len + 1);
         // if search in left subtree fails to find such path only then we search in the right subtree
         if (l == Integer.MAX_VALUE) {
             l = minLenSumPathBST(root.right, remainingSum, len + 1);
         }

         return l;
        
    }
    // If remaining sum is greater than current node value then we search remaining in the right subtree.
    else {
      int l = minLenSumPathBST(root.right, remainingSum, len + 1);
         // if search in right subtree fails to find such path only then we search in the left subtree
         if (l == Integer.MAX_VALUE) {
             l = minLenSumPathBST(root.left, remainingSum, len + 1);
         }

         return l;
    }
}

Read full article from Minimum length sum pathZahid Rahman